The net value of work

November 16, 2026

THE WORK ATLASUNITED STATES / NOV 2026
100 occupations. A distribution, not a verdict.

What does a worker
add, after the costs?

Useful output, minus compensation, coordination, and the value of available alternatives. Explore the range within a job—and what AI changes.

106.12M U.S. jobs represented100 largest occupationsResearch & assumptions ↗
EXPLORATORY MODEL Employment and pay are observed. Every value distribution is an editorial estimate informed by research. This is not a measure of a person’s worth or total social welfare.
TechnologyEMPLOYMENT RANK 15 / 100

Software engineers

1,687,890 jobs$148,100 mean annualized wageMay 2025 observations
MEDIAN INDEX57/100

+0.28× net compensation

BELOW BREAK-EVEN44%

Modeled share with negative net value

99TH PERCENTILE+11.0×

Net value / annual compensation

Share of modeled workersHover or focus a bar
Software engineers: modeled median index 57, 43.7% below break-evenForty bins from index zero to one hundred. Fifty is break-even. Bar height is the percent of modeled worker-and-workplace combinations in the bin, not survey observations. Negative net contributions appear left of fifty.0%2%4%6%8%BREAK-EVEN0≤ −100×25−3.5×500 net75+3.5×100≥ +100×
Negative contribution Positive contributionIndex · nonlinear scale
Net contribution is measured in multiples of annual compensation. The index compresses the tails; 50 means zero net value. The dotted line with a dot marks the median. Bars describe an assumed population distribution, not confidence in the estimate.
Net contributionP10−1.8×P50+0.3×P90+3.1×P99.9+73.5×
Change the assumptions Explore sensitivity ↗
Under the squeeze and upside assumptions, this job’s modeled median spans −0.30× to +0.85×. This is a scenario range, not a statistical confidence interval.
01 / THE DISTRIBUTION

Why this shape

Unused features, rework and review burden create a negative tail; reusable systems create a long positive tail. The median is not empirically known.

02 / AI IN 2026

What changes

Coding studies disagree across settings. Late-2026 agents expand possible output, but review, product judgment and demand remain constraints.

Both explanations are model judgments informed by the sources below. No cited study estimates this occupation’s full net-value distribution.
Evidence for this occupation 9 sources ↗
BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook · Technology ↗2026 edition · accessed November 16, 2026

Occupational duties, physical requirements and work setting inform the qualitative task assessment.

Describes work. Does not measure net utility or validate our model parameters.

BLS · National occupational employment and wages ↗May 2025 data · released May 15, 2026

Employment and annual mean wages; the 100 largest non-overlapping leaf occupations in this table define the sample.

Payroll employment, not the whole workforce. Excludes self-employed workers and most agricultural and household employment. Annualized wages are not actual annual earnings for part-time workers.

ILO · Generative AI and jobs ↗May 20, 2025

Task exposure is highest in clerical work. Physical and interpersonal tasks limit whole-job substitution.

Exposure is potential technical capability, not realized replacement or a measure of worker value. Our occupation exposure ratings are judgments, not copied ILO scores.

ILO · What exposure indicators do and do not tell us ↗April 17, 2026

Exposure measures must be combined with adoption, feasibility and actual employment evidence.

An exposed task does not imply that a job is unnecessary or economically unproductive.

Cui et al. · Three developer field experiments ↗June 2025

Across 4,867 developers, access to a coding assistant increased completed tasks by about 26%, with heterogeneous gains.

Task counts are not product impact, profits or current agentic capability. Industry-affiliated study.

METR · Experienced open-source developers ↗July 10, 2025

Sixteen experienced developers completing 246 tasks took 19% longer with early-2025 AI tools.

Small sample in familiar mature repositories. Not a claim about all developers or late-2026 models.

METR · Developer experiment update ↗February 24, 2026

Later results suggest more speedup, but selection and time-measurement problems prevent a reliable current estimate.

The authors explicitly warn against treating the follow-up as a clean productivity estimate.

Anthropic · Employment at the AI frontier ↗October 16, 2026

Internal data associate agent adoption with more code, sales and contracts per person, while human attention becomes a bottleneck.

One unusually AI-intensive company; observational, vendor-authored evidence. Does not establish 10× or 100× worker-value prevalence.

Stanford · AI and labor demand in 41 countries ↗Revised November 5, 2026

An instrumented event study finds a lower junior employment share after adoption, mainly through senior employment growth.

Working paper; employment composition is not net output, and causal interpretation depends on the design assumptions.

Inspect this job’s parameters All are assumptions ↗

Official BLS occupation: Software developers. Parameters below are priors, not values estimated from wages or fitted to a worker dataset.

Gross median
1.4×
Spread parameter
1.35×
Gross P99
10×
Coordination cost
0.3×
AI output gain
25%
Alternative discount
0.15×

At this job’s average wage and a generic 1.43× benefits factor, one compensation unit is approximately $211,571. Wage data are context, not evidence of contribution. We do not estimate an individual worker’s pay.

HOW TO READ THIS

The assumptions are part of the graphic.

A narrow definition of “utility”

The model asks what a worker adds for an employer or service recipient over one year, net of compensation, coordination burden, tooling, and a discount for available alternatives. Output means attributable value after nonlabor inputs, not sales revenue. Capital and team effects cannot be perfectly separated.

Salary is income to someone else, so this is not total social welfare. Health, dignity, long-run student outcomes, environmental effects and redistribution are not comprehensively priced. These cross-job comparisons depend on contestable valuations.

Research informs the shape, not the numbers

BLS establishes job prevalence, pay and duties. Experiments inform plausible AI mechanisms; observational 2026 studies add current context. The gross-output medians, spread, tails, coordination costs and AI coefficients are explicit editorial priors. No evidence establishes that the typical software engineer has zero net value.

The unit is a worker in a workplace, including role design, resources, demand and organizational fit—not fixed individual talent. Unused output is assumed to have no value.

One common scale

Net = gross contribution × output scenario × (1 + AI gain) − 1 compensation unit − coordination − alternative discount − AI tooling. Coordination does not include the worker’s own pay. The alternative discount is a sensitivity assumption, not a measured counterfactual replacement cost.

Index = 50 + 50 × asinh(4 × net) / asinh(400), clipped to 0–100. Zero net maps to 50. ±100 compensation units map to the endpoints. The index is nonlinear; a score of 80 is not twice a score of 40.

Population spread ≠ certainty

Ten quantile anchors define each assumed distribution; linear interpolation and 10,000 deterministic integration points produce the bars. Those points are not observed workers. Tails above +100× remain in the final bin and in percentile statistics.

The squeeze scenario uses 0.8× baseline output, half the AI gain and 1.6× the alternative discount. Upside uses 1.15× output, 1.6× the gain and half the discount. None is a forecast or confidence interval. Use comparisons to examine assumptions, not to rank human worth.

Research bibliography & coverage 17 studies and data releases + 17 BLS occupation groups ↗

The 100 largest leaf rows in the May 2025 OEWS national table are sorted by employment, with aggregates removed. They represent 106,118,330 payroll jobs. Data were released May 15, 2026; research was checked through November 16, 2026. This is a U.S. model, not a global estimate.

OEWS wages exclude benefits and stock compensation. Most annual wages are hourly rates × 2,080; for part-time jobs they are full-time equivalents. We retain the data’s date rather than inventing 2026 occupation counts or wage estimates.

BLS · National occupational employment and wages ↗May 2025 data · released May 15, 2026

Employment and annual mean wages; the 100 largest non-overlapping leaf occupations in this table define the sample.

Payroll employment, not the whole workforce. Excludes self-employed workers and most agricultural and household employment. Annualized wages are not actual annual earnings for part-time workers.

BLS · Employer compensation costs ↗June 2026 data · released September 9, 2026

Private-industry wages are 70% of compensation; compensation / wages is approximately 1.43.

A national average, not an occupation-specific benefit rate; government and part-time benefit costs differ. Used only for the illustrative dollar conversion.

ILO · Generative AI and jobs ↗May 20, 2025

Task exposure is highest in clerical work. Physical and interpersonal tasks limit whole-job substitution.

Exposure is potential technical capability, not realized replacement or a measure of worker value. Our occupation exposure ratings are judgments, not copied ILO scores.

ILO · What exposure indicators do and do not tell us ↗April 17, 2026

Exposure measures must be combined with adoption, feasibility and actual employment evidence.

An exposed task does not imply that a job is unnecessary or economically unproductive.

Anthropic · Observed AI exposure ↗March 5, 2026

Observed use is much smaller than theoretical capability; no systematic unemployment rise was detected in highly exposed occupations in the study window.

Vendor-specific observational usage; neither a representative worker sample nor a causal productivity estimate.

Anthropic · Employment at the AI frontier ↗October 16, 2026

Internal data associate agent adoption with more code, sales and contracts per person, while human attention becomes a bottleneck.

One unusually AI-intensive company; observational, vendor-authored evidence. Does not establish 10× or 100× worker-value prevalence.

Stanford · AI and labor demand in 41 countries ↗Revised November 5, 2026

An instrumented event study finds a lower junior employment share after adoption, mainly through senior employment growth.

Working paper; employment composition is not net output, and causal interpretation depends on the design assumptions.

Cui et al. · Three developer field experiments ↗June 2025

Across 4,867 developers, access to a coding assistant increased completed tasks by about 26%, with heterogeneous gains.

Task counts are not product impact, profits or current agentic capability. Industry-affiliated study.

METR · Experienced open-source developers ↗July 10, 2025

Sixteen experienced developers completing 246 tasks took 19% longer with early-2025 AI tools.

Small sample in familiar mature repositories. Not a claim about all developers or late-2026 models.

METR · Developer experiment update ↗February 24, 2026

Later results suggest more speedup, but selection and time-measurement problems prevent a reliable current estimate.

The authors explicitly warn against treating the follow-up as a clean productivity estimate.

Brynjolfsson, Li & Raymond · Generative AI at work ↗Revised November 2023

In the working-paper sample of 5,179 support agents, issues resolved per hour rose 14%; novice and lower-skill workers gained more.

One firm and an older assistant. The published version and sample differ; this page uses the cited working-paper result. Not an absolute net-value estimate.

Dell’Acqua et al. · The jagged technological frontier ↗2023 experiment · paper retrieved November 2026

In a 758-consultant experiment, AI helped on tasks within its capabilities and reduced accuracy on an out-of-frontier task.

Task-level treatment effects; applying the mechanism to other knowledge occupations is an extrapolation.

Dillon et al. · Shifting work patterns ↗Revised November 2025

A randomized study across 66 firms and 7,137 workers found email time savings, but no detectable broad shift in task quantity or composition.

Time saved is not automatically economic surplus; organizations must put it to productive use.

Humlum & Vestergaard · Small labor-market effects ↗2025 · early-adoption Danish data

Survey and administrative evidence shows modest time savings and little detectable change in earnings or recorded hours in the initial study period.

Different labor market and early models. A useful counterweight to extrapolating frontier-company results.

Lazear, Shaw & Stanton · The value of bosses ↗Revised June 2013

In one service company, supervisor quality materially changed team output and worker retention.

Supports including team spillovers, not any particular managerial median or a universal multiplier.

Chetty, Friedman & Rockoff · Teacher value added ↗Revised May 2014

Teacher quality predicts later student outcomes, including earnings; benefits can accrue long after the work.

Does not identify total value relative to no teacher or a comparable 2026 annual employer surplus. Long-run benefits are not added to this narrow model.

Bartel et al. · Human capital in nursing teams ↗2011 working paper · published 2014

Nurse staffing and team-specific experience affect patient outcomes in VA hospitals.

Supports team and safety mechanisms, not the numerical value distributions of all healthcare workers.

BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook · Care & health ↗2026 edition · accessed November 16, 2026

Occupational duties, physical requirements and work setting inform the qualitative task assessment.

Describes work. Does not measure net utility or validate our model parameters.

BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook · Sales & retail ↗2026 edition · accessed November 16, 2026

Occupational duties, physical requirements and work setting inform the qualitative task assessment.

Describes work. Does not measure net utility or validate our model parameters.

BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook · Service & hospitality ↗2026 edition · accessed November 16, 2026

Occupational duties, physical requirements and work setting inform the qualitative task assessment.

Describes work. Does not measure net utility or validate our model parameters.

BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook · Management ↗2026 edition · accessed November 16, 2026

Occupational duties, physical requirements and work setting inform the qualitative task assessment.

Describes work. Does not measure net utility or validate our model parameters.

BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook · Transport & logistics ↗2026 edition · accessed November 16, 2026

Occupational duties, physical requirements and work setting inform the qualitative task assessment.

Describes work. Does not measure net utility or validate our model parameters.

BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook · Office & administration ↗2026 edition · accessed November 16, 2026

Occupational duties, physical requirements and work setting inform the qualitative task assessment.

Describes work. Does not measure net utility or validate our model parameters.

BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook · Service & hospitality ↗2026 edition · accessed November 16, 2026

Occupational duties, physical requirements and work setting inform the qualitative task assessment.

Describes work. Does not measure net utility or validate our model parameters.

BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook · Technology ↗2026 edition · accessed November 16, 2026

Occupational duties, physical requirements and work setting inform the qualitative task assessment.

Describes work. Does not measure net utility or validate our model parameters.

BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook · Trades & production ↗2026 edition · accessed November 16, 2026

Occupational duties, physical requirements and work setting inform the qualitative task assessment.

Describes work. Does not measure net utility or validate our model parameters.

BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook · Business & finance ↗2026 edition · accessed November 16, 2026

Occupational duties, physical requirements and work setting inform the qualitative task assessment.

Describes work. Does not measure net utility or validate our model parameters.

BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook · Education & community ↗2026 edition · accessed November 16, 2026

Occupational duties, physical requirements and work setting inform the qualitative task assessment.

Describes work. Does not measure net utility or validate our model parameters.

BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook · Trades & production ↗2026 edition · accessed November 16, 2026

Occupational duties, physical requirements and work setting inform the qualitative task assessment.

Describes work. Does not measure net utility or validate our model parameters.

BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook · Law & public safety ↗2026 edition · accessed November 16, 2026

Occupational duties, physical requirements and work setting inform the qualitative task assessment.

Describes work. Does not measure net utility or validate our model parameters.

BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook · Trades & production ↗2026 edition · accessed November 16, 2026

Occupational duties, physical requirements and work setting inform the qualitative task assessment.

Describes work. Does not measure net utility or validate our model parameters.

BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook · Law & public safety ↗2026 edition · accessed November 16, 2026

Occupational duties, physical requirements and work setting inform the qualitative task assessment.

Describes work. Does not measure net utility or validate our model parameters.

BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook · Service & hospitality ↗2026 edition · accessed November 16, 2026

Occupational duties, physical requirements and work setting inform the qualitative task assessment.

Describes work. Does not measure net utility or validate our model parameters.

BLS Occupational Outlook Handbook · Education & community ↗2026 edition · accessed November 16, 2026

Occupational duties, physical requirements and work setting inform the qualitative task assessment.

Describes work. Does not measure net utility or validate our model parameters.

RAYMOND XU / WORK IN PROGRESSResearch and model drafted with AI · v0.1